Uniquely Human Judgment

Definition

Uniquely Human Judgment examines uniquely human judgment within the broader domain of capabilities and forms of value that remain grounded in embodied, moral, relational and lived human experience.

Why this matters

Uniquely Human Judgment can materially affect human agency, capability, belonging, livelihoods, culture, trust, resilience and long-term societal outcomes.

Research questions

Under which conditions does uniquely human judgment improve human and system outcomes, how do effects vary across populations and contexts, and what safeguards prevent dependency, exclusion, distortion or loss of agency?

Hypotheses

A transparent, participatory and human-directed approach to uniquely human judgment, with explicit safeguards and longitudinal evaluation, will improve judgement quality; contextual sensitivity; relational trust; moral imagination; tacit transfer; identity; dignity compared with opaque, automation-first or short-term approaches.

Proposed methods

comparative human–AI task studies; ethnography; expert elicitation; moral reasoning studies; phenomenological interviews; longitudinal observation; literature and policy review; expert and affected-user interviews; reproducibility testing; methods adapted specifically to Uniquely Human Judgment

Stakeholders and beneficiaries

creators; cultural custodians; communities; educators; researchers; publishers; platforms; collecting societies; libraries; archives; museums; regulators; funders